Public Record Service

Energy and permitting policy, read from the public record.

Register entry No. 0042Floor orderH.R. 2347

Senate invokes cloture on permitting substitute SA 6883 to H.R. 2347, 70-27, starting up to 30 hours of post-cloture debate

Roll Call Vote No. 264 on November 16 limits debate on the Capito substitute. Senators filed amendments SA 6891 through SA 7008 before the vote, on transmission voltage thresholds, data center curtailment and pending court remands; none of them is pending on the floor.

Entered by
Public Record Service
Date
Sources
12 cited

Summary

“After no more than thirty hours of consideration of the measure, motion, or other matter on which cloture has been invoked, the Senate shall proceed, without any further debate on any question, to vote on the final disposition thereof.” That sentence of Senate Rule XXII now governs SA 6883, the permitting substitute to H.R. 2347 [9]. At 6:27 p.m. on November 16, 2026, the Senate voted 70-27 to invoke cloture on the amendment, which Majority Leader John Thune offered for Sen. Shelley Moore Capito, clearing the three-fifths requirement in Roll Call Vote No. 264 [1]. H.R. 2347 remains formally the Survivor Justice Tax Prevention Act, the House-passed vehicle for the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act [5].

What the record shows

The tally, set against November 9

The Senate’s roll call lists 49 Republicans, 20 Democrats and Sen. Angus King (I-Maine) in favor; 24 Democrats, Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) and two Republicans, Sens. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) and Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), against [1]. Sens. Ashley Moody (R-Fla.), Jim Risch (R-Idaho) and Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) did not vote [1].

A week earlier, cloture on the motion to proceed to H.R. 2347 passed 73-25 [2]. Read against each other, the two roll calls show five senators in different columns:

Senator Nov. 9 (Vote 257) Nov. 16 (Vote 264)
Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) Yea Nay
Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) Yea Nay
Ashley Moody (R-Fla.) Yea Not voting
Jim Risch (R-Idaho) Yea Not voting
Tim Sheehy (R-Mont.) Not voting Yea

Every other senator cast the same vote both times [1, 2]. Rounds voted no on both [1, 2].

What the cloture motions cover

Two cloture motions were entered on November 11: one on SA 6883, and one on the bill, with the vote on the second to “occur upon disposition of” the substitute [3]. A unanimous consent agreement on November 12 set the order for Monday: the vote on confirming Daniel Domenico to the Tenth Circuit at 5:30 p.m., then, if he was confirmed, the cloture vote on SA 6883 [4]. The Senate confirmed Domenico 51-46 at 5:27 p.m., an hour before the cloture vote [1, 12].

Amendments on file

Between November 11 and 12, senators submitted amendments numbered SA 6891 through SA 7008, almost all to SA 6883, and each was “ordered to lie on the table” [6, 7]. Several reach provisions this site has tracked in the substitute:

  • Transmission voltage. SA 6883 would rewrite section 216(b) of the Federal Power Act so that FERC permits cover facilities “capable of transmitting electric energy at a voltage of not less than 230 kilovolts,” or lines needed to connect them [8]. SA 6902, from Sen. Ted Budd (R-N.C.) with Rounds and Sen. Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.) among its cosponsors, would strike that paragraph and set the floor at 345 kilovolts [7]. Current law lets FERC issue a permit only inside a national interest electric transmission corridor designated by the Secretary of Energy [10].
  • Landowners. SA 6984 and SA 7006, from Sen. Jerry Moran (R-Kan.) with Sens. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) and Eric Schmitt (R-Mo.), would have FERC require a permit applicant to file a land restoration plan for “farmland, ranchland, and Tribal land” and give a copy to each affected landowner, with corrective-action orders at the permit holder’s cost [7].
  • Data center curtailment. SA 6934, from Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), would add to section 2107 a directive that FERC open section 206 investigations within 90 days of enactment [7]. Their purpose would be tariff procedures to curtail computational loads that have “failed to bring sufficient new generation to the grid to meet its peak demand, plus a reserve margin,” no later than a NERC Energy Emergency Alert level 1 [7]. Any compensation for curtailed load could not come from other ratepayers [7].
  • Pending remands. SA 6933, also from Van Hollen, would let a court grant an agency’s request for voluntary remand, if pending as of November 11, 2026 or substantially similar, only if the agency shows grounds under the substitute’s listed exceptions [7].
  • Grid resilience grants. SA 6909, offered by Sen. John Barrasso (R-Wyo.) for Sens. John Cornyn (R-Texas) and Alex Padilla (D-Calif.), would change “2022 through 2026” to “2027 through 2031” in section 40101 of the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act [7].

Others would rewrite parts of the substitute’s historic preservation text, adding a rule of construction for Indian tribes and Native Hawaiian organizations (SA 6999, Sen. Lisa Murkowski with five Democrats), and to Clean Water Act section 404(c) determinations (SA 6992, Sens. Maria Cantwell and Murkowski) [7].

Where it sits in the process

What happens after cloture on SA 6883?

Rule XXII gives each senator at most one hour of debate on the matter, bars non-germane and dilatory amendments, and permits only amendments submitted in writing by the filing deadlines [9]. The first-degree deadline for SA 6883 and the bill fell at 1 p.m. on November 12 [3]. After no more than thirty hours, the Senate votes on the substitute “to the exclusion of all amendments not then actually pending” [9]. The Daily Digest’s pending list for H.R. 2347 shows only SA 6883 and Thune’s amendments 6884 through 6890, which change the enactment date, together with his motion to commit [3].

When could the Senate vote on final passage?

The order is fixed by the November 11 motions: disposition of SA 6883, then the cloture vote on H.R. 2347 as amended, then another post-cloture period of up to thirty hours before passage [3, 9]. The thirty hours can be extended by a three-fifths vote [9]. No date for final passage appears in the record this report draws on.

Thune told the Senate on November 11 that “the sooner we finish permitting, the more time we will have for additional priorities” [6]. Because H.R. 2347 is a House bill, Senate passage would return it to the House, as this site’s November 12 report set out.

What the record does not show

  • Floor debate on November 16. The Record for that day had not been published at this report’s deadline, so any statements around the vote, and any consent agreement for the remaining time, are absent here.
  • Reasons for the vote changes. Neither Cortez Masto nor Hawley explains a switch in the record cited [6, 7].
  • Amendment votes. No roll call on any of SA 6891 through SA 7008 had been held, and none was pending [1, 3].
  • A House schedule. The House met from 10 a.m. to 10:02 a.m. on November 13 and listed its program for Tuesday, November 17, as “To be announced” [5].

Positions on the record

Leadership. Thune, on November 12, cited a Washington, D.C., sewer line whose repair he said was held up by federal permitting and said the bill “will streamline and reform the permitting process to ensure that projects are approved or rejected in a timely fashion” [7]. Barrasso said the same day that “Fixing our country’s permitting system is one of the best ways to provide that relief,” and that “Democrats in the House and Democrats who will be coming to the House in January are not so sure” [7].

Amendment sponsors. The filed amendments are the clearest statement of what senators who voted for cloture still want changed. Budd’s 345-kilovolt threshold carries Republican names, Rounds among them [7]. The Moran landowner amendment does as well [7]. Van Hollen’s curtailment and remand amendments come from a senator who voted no on both cloture votes [1, 2, 7].

Outside groups. The Union of Concerned Scientists said on November 9 that the weekend revisions improved the transmission and permitting certainty provisions but that the bill, if enacted as drafted, “would be the most significant legislative reversal in environmental and community protections in decades” [11]. David Watkins, its director of government affairs for climate and energy, urged senators to “go back to the negotiating table” [11].

Reading-room questions

Questions readers bring to this record, answered from the documents cited below.

Did the Senate pass the permitting bill on November 16?
No. The 70-27 vote on November 16 invoked cloture on SA 6883, the Capito substitute, which limits further debate on it [1]. A separate cloture vote on H.R. 2347 itself is set to follow disposition of the substitute, and final passage comes after that [3].
How long can the Senate debate the permitting substitute after cloture?
Senate Rule XXII allows no more than thirty hours of consideration after cloture is invoked, unless three-fifths of senators vote to extend it [9]. The record cited here shows no agreement setting the remaining time on SA 6883 [5].
Which senators changed their votes between the November 9 and November 16 cloture votes?
Sens. Catherine Cortez Masto (D-Nev.) and Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) voted yea on November 9 and nay on November 16 [1, 2]. Sens. Ashley Moody (R-Fla.) and Jim Risch (R-Idaho) voted on November 9 but not on November 16, and Sen. Tim Sheehy (R-Mont.) voted yea on November 16 after not voting on November 9 [1, 2].
Will the Senate vote on the amendments senators filed to SA 6883?
None is pending. The amendments filed November 11 and 12 were ordered to lie on the table, and the Daily Digest lists only Majority Leader Thune's date-change amendments as pending [3, 6, 7]. Under Rule XXII, the final vote after cloture excludes amendments not then actually pending [9].
Would the permitting bill raise the voltage threshold for FERC transmission permits?
Not as written. SA 6883 covers facilities of at least 230 kilovolts [8]. Amendment SA 6902, filed by Sen. Budd with Sens. Rounds and Cramer among its cosponsors, would raise that to 345 kilovolts, but it is not pending [3, 7].

Note on sourcing

The Congressional Record for November 16 had not been published as of this report, so floor remarks made before or after the cloture vote, and any unanimous consent agreement reached that evening on the remaining time or on amendment votes, are not reflected here; the vote itself is taken from the Senate's roll call record. The descriptions of filed amendments cover a selection and are drawn from the amendment text printed in the Record; this report does not characterize every one of them. The comparison of Vote No. 264 with Vote No. 257 is this report's own reading of the two roll calls. Statements by senators about why they changed their votes, if any, do not appear in the record this report draws on.

Sources

  1. Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote No. 264: On the Cloture Motion, S.Amdt. 6883 to H.R. 2347U.S. Senate, November 16, 2026 · senate.gov
  2. Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote No. 257: On Cloture on the Motion to Proceed, H.R. 2347U.S. Senate, November 9, 2026 · senate.gov
  3. Congressional Record, Daily Digest (November 11, 2026), Senate, pp. D1012 ff.U.S. Senate, November 11, 2026 · govinfo.gov
  4. Congressional Record, Daily Digest (November 12, 2026), SenateU.S. Senate, November 12, 2026 · govinfo.gov
  5. Congressional Record, Daily Digest (November 13, 2026), pp. D1021-D1022U.S. Senate, November 13, 2026 · govinfo.gov
  6. Congressional Record, Senate (November 11, 2026): remarks of Sen. Thune, p. S5567; Text of Amendments, SA 6891-SA 6900U.S. Senate, November 11, 2026 · govinfo.gov
  7. Congressional Record, Senate (November 12, 2026): remarks of Sens. Thune and Barrasso, pp. S5583-S5584; Text of Amendments, SA 6901-SA 7008U.S. Senate, November 12, 2026 · govinfo.gov
  8. Congressional Record, Senate (November 10, 2026), Text of Amendments, SA 6883U.S. Senate, November 10, 2026 · govinfo.gov
  9. Standing Rules of the Senate, Rule XXII, Precedence of MotionsU.S. Senate Committee on Rules and Administration, accessed 2026-11-17 · rules.senate.gov
  10. 16 U.S. Code § 824p, Siting of interstate electric transmission facilitiesU.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-17 · law.cornell.edu
  11. Weekend Amendment Fails to Address Fossil Fuel Giveaways in Senate Permitting Deal (statement by David Watkins)Union of Concerned Scientists, November 9, 2026 · ucs.org
  12. Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote No. 263: On the Nomination PN999-2, Daniel Desmond DomenicoU.S. Senate, November 16, 2026 · senate.gov

Subject headings

Cross-references

Other register entries filed under the same subject headings.

  1. No. 0037 · Floor order · 6 shared headingsSenate takes up H.R. 2347 after 73-25 cloture vote; Capito substitute SA 6883 carries revised permitting text
  2. No. 0045 · Bill · 5 shared headingsSenate passes H.R. 2347 with permitting substitute SA 6883, 62-33, Roll Call Vote No. 270; bill returns to the House
  3. No. 0031 · Floor order · 5 shared headingsSenate order sets Nov. 9 cloture vote on motion to proceed to H.R. 2347, the vehicle for a permitting package