Register entry No. 0045BillH.R. 2347
Senate passes H.R. 2347 with permitting substitute SA 6883, 62-33, Roll Call Vote No. 270; bill returns to the House
The Senate adopted the Capito substitute 69-27 on November 18, invoked cloture on the bill 65-31, and passed it November 19. Democratic support fell from 21 on the first test vote to 14 on passage. The House has to act on the Senate's text before January 3.
- Entered by
- Public Record Service
- Date
- Sources
- 9 cited
Summary
The bill the Senate passed on November 19 is still listed on the Senate’s roll call page as H.R. 2347, “A bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to exclude from gross income any damages, other than punitive damages, received on account of any sexual acts or sexual contact” [1]. Its text is now the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, substituted by amendment No. 6883 the day before [4]. The question “On Passage of the Bill (H.R. 2347, as Amended)” carried 62 to 33, with five senators not voting, in Roll Call Vote No. 270 [1]. Because the House passed a different text of H.R. 2347 in April, the bill goes back to the House [8].
What the record shows
Three votes on November 18
The Senate resumed on the bill under a unanimous-consent order entered November 17. It set post-cloture time on SA 6883 to expire at 11:45 a.m. and provided that if Sen. Jeff Merkley or his designee raised a point of order against the substitute, the Senate would vote on it then [3].
Merkley did. He raised a point of order that the substitute violated section 4106 of H. Con. Res. 71 of the 115th Congress, the Senate pay-as-you-go rule [5]. Sen. Shelley Moore Capito moved under section 904 of the Congressional Budget Act of 1974 to waive it [5]. The waiver required three-fifths of senators duly chosen and sworn and drew 70 yeas to 26 nays in Vote No. 266, so the point of order fell [4].
The Senate then adopted the Capito substitute, 69 to 27, in Vote No. 267 [4]. Majority Leader John Thune’s four date-change amendments, Nos. 6884 through 6887, were disposed of without recorded votes: two tabled by voice vote and two that fell with them [4]. Cloture on the bill itself followed, 65 to 31, in Vote No. 268, and a second consent order counted time during adjournment and recess as post-cloture time [4]. None of the amendments numbered SA 6891 through SA 7008, which this site tracked in its November 17 report on the substitute’s cloture vote, is listed in the November 18 Digest as receiving a vote [4].
How the yeas changed across six votes
The six roll calls on H.R. 2347 show the margin narrowing at each step, almost entirely among Democrats [1, 2]:
| Vote | Date | Question | Result | Democratic yeas | Republican yeas |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 257 | Nov. 9 | Cloture on motion to proceed | 73-25 | 21 | 51 |
| 264 | Nov. 16 | Cloture on SA 6883 | 70-27 | 20 | 49 |
| 266 | Nov. 18 | Budget Act waiver | 70-26 | 18 | 51 |
| 267 | Nov. 18 | Adoption of SA 6883 | 69-27 | 17 | 51 |
| 268 | Nov. 18 | Cloture on the bill | 65-31 | 14 | 50 |
| 270 | Nov. 19 | Passage | 62-33 | 14 | 47 |
Sen. Angus King (I-Maine) voted yes and Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) no on every one of the six [1, 2]. Of the 33 nays on passage, 30 were Democrats, one was Sanders and two were Republicans, Sens. Josh Hawley of Missouri and Mike Rounds of South Dakota [1]. Rounds voted no on all six [1, 2].
Eight senators who voted for cloture on the motion to proceed on November 9 voted against passage: Democrats Richard Blumenthal, Catherine Cortez Masto, Kirsten Gillibrand, Andy Kim, Jon Ossoff, Jeanne Shaheen and Raphael Warnock, and Republican Hawley [1, 2]. No senator moved the other way across those two votes [1, 2]. Sen. Gary Peters voted no on cloture on the bill and yes on passage [1, 2]. Minority Leader Chuck Schumer voted yes on passage [1].
Sens. Bill Cassidy, John Cornyn, Mitch McConnell and Tommy Tuberville, Republicans who voted for cloture on the substitute, did not vote on passage; nor did Democrat Chris Murphy [1, 2]. The 62 yeas were above the 60 that cloture had required, though passage itself needed only a majority [1].
Where it sits in the process
What happens to H.R. 2347 in the House now?
The House passed H.R. 2347 by voice vote on April 27, 2026, with different text [8]. The Senate’s version replaces that text with the permitting package, whose sections this site walked through in its November 12 report on the substitute. The House has to vote on the Senate’s version [8]. It can take the bill up under a rule, which needs a simple majority, or under suspension of the rules, which needs two-thirds [8]. If it passes the Senate text without change, the bill goes to the President; if it amends it, the bill returns to the Senate [8]. As of the morning of November 20, the tracker this report draws on listed no House date [8].
The calendar is short. The terms of the current senators and representatives end at noon on January 3, 2027, and the next Congress convenes that day unless a law sets another [9]. The Associated Press reported that House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries, who is expected to become speaker in January, criticized the bill in early November, with his office saying it “falls short” in a number of areas [6].
What the record does not show
- The November 19 floor debate. The Congressional Record for the day of passage was not yet printed, so any statements before Vote No. 270, and any consent order governing House-bound paperwork, are not available here [1].
- Why eight senators changed their votes. Sen. Cortez Masto’s shift came first: she voted yes on November 9 and no on every vote from November 16 on [2]. The other seven held their yes votes at least through cloture on the substitute [2]. The record this report draws on carries no explanation from any of the eight.
- The House leadership’s plan. No statement from the House majority leadership or the chairs of the House committees with jurisdiction on the Senate-passed text appears in the sources here.
- The cost. Merkley said on the floor that the Congressional Budget Office found the bill “will increase the deficit by hundreds of millions of dollars, and that is assuming everything goes right,” and that outside groups put a possible cost “into the tens of billions” if projects are blocked by other means [5]. This report does not draw on the CBO estimate and does not verify either figure.
- The White House position on wind. The AP reported that President Trump told reporters on November 9, “I will not approve wind turbines,” after being told wind was part of the bill [6]. Whether the President would sign the Senate text, and on what terms, is not on the record.
Positions on the record
Sponsors and supporters. Sen. John Barrasso opened November 18 by calling for passage of “historic” permitting legislation and said the bill “streamlines environmental reviews” and reins in what he called abusive lawsuits [5]. He also addressed the next chamber directly: “Radical Democrats in the House need to pay attention” [5]. Sen. Kevin Cramer said the bill is supported by investor-owned utilities, rural electric cooperatives, the White House, renewable energy groups and oil and gas producers, among others, and asked colleagues to “send it to the House with a lot of momentum” [5]. Sen. Lisa Murkowski called it “the most substantive bipartisan agreement on permitting reform that we have reached since I have been serving here in the Senate” [5]. Earlier, Sen. Martin Heinrich said, “Americans can’t afford to wait for lower electricity prices. We need to pass this bill now” [6].
Opponents. Environmental groups and tribal organizations urged lawmakers to hold the bill until the next Congress, when Democrats take control of both chambers, Common Dreams reported [7]. Elizabeth Bast of Oil Change International said, “BAAJA is not a compromise—it’s exactly what the fossil fuel industry wants” [7]. The AP reported that the Sierra Club and the National Wildlife Federation opposed it over its limits on judicial review and changes to NEPA and the Endangered Species Act [6].
Merkley’s floor statement before the pay-go vote stated the procedural objection most directly. He said there “has never been a public hearing on this bill,” in either committee of jurisdiction or in either chamber, and argued that “it is appropriate that we consider it in 2027” [5].
Reading-room questions
Questions readers bring to this record, answered from the documents cited below.
- Did the Senate pass the permitting bill?
- Yes. The Senate passed H.R. 2347, as amended by the permitting substitute SA 6883, by 62 to 33 on November 19, 2026, in Roll Call Vote No. 270 [1].
- What does the House have to do now with H.R. 2347?
- The House passed a different text of H.R. 2347 in April, so it has to vote on the Senate's version; if it changes the text, the bill goes back to the Senate [8]. No House date had been set as of November 20 [8].
- How many Democrats voted for the Senate permitting bill?
- Fourteen Democrats and Sen. Angus King (I-Maine) voted yes on final passage, along with 47 Republicans [1]. Twenty-one Democrats had voted to proceed to the bill on November 9 [2].
- Is the permitting bill still called the Survivor Justice Tax Prevention Act?
- Officially, yes. The Senate's roll call page lists H.R. 2347 under its original title, a bill to exclude certain damages from gross income, and the Daily Digest calls it the legislative vehicle for the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act [1, 3].
- What is the deadline for the House to pass the Senate permitting text?
- The terms of the current House and Senate end at noon on January 3, 2027, under the Twentieth Amendment [9]. That is the outer limit for this Congress to act on the Senate-passed bill.
Note on sourcing
The bound Congressional Record and Daily Digest for November 19 had not been published at the time of writing, so floor statements made on the day of passage are not reflected here; the passage tally and the individual votes come from the Senate's roll call page for Vote No. 270. Party counts and the vote-to-vote changes in the table are this report's own tallies from the six Senate roll call pages. Sen. Merkley's reference to a Congressional Budget Office deficit estimate is reported as he stated it on the floor; this report does not draw on the CBO estimate itself. No statement by House leadership on the Senate-passed text, and no House floor schedule for it, appears in the record this report draws on. Sens. Cortez Masto, Blumenthal, Gillibrand, Kim, Ossoff, Shaheen, Warnock and Hawley, who voted to proceed on November 9 and against passage on November 19, made no statement explaining the change in the record this report draws on.
Sources
- Roll Call Vote 119th Congress, 2nd Session, Vote No. 270: On Passage of the Bill (H.R. 2347, as Amended)U.S. Senate, November 19, 2026 ·
senate.gov - Roll Call Votes Nos. 257, 264, 266, 267 and 268 (119th Congress, 2nd Session) on H.R. 2347 and S.Amdt. 6883U.S. Senate, November 9-18, 2026 ·
senate.gov - Congressional Record, Daily Digest (November 17, 2026), Senate, p. D1032U.S. Senate, November 17, 2026 ·
govinfo.gov - Congressional Record, Daily Digest (November 18, 2026), SenateU.S. Senate, November 18, 2026 ·
govinfo.gov - Congressional Record, Senate (November 18, 2026): remarks of Sens. Barrasso, Thune, Merkley, Capito, Cramer and Murkowski on H.R. 2347, pp. S5729-S5737 and followingU.S. Senate, November 18, 2026 ·
govinfo.gov - Senate advances sweeping energy legislation in first major action since midterm elections (by Matthew Daly and Jennifer McDermott)Associated Press (via OPB), November 10, 2026 ·
opb.org - Senate advances permitting reformCommon Dreams, November 10, 2026 ·
commondreams.org - BAAJA bill trackerMore Than Just Parks, accessed 2026-11-20 ·
morethanjustparks.com - Twentieth Amendment, Constitution of the United StatesConstitution of the United States, accessed 2026-11-20 ·
law.cornell.edu
Subject headings
Cross-references
Other register entries filed under the same subject headings.
- No. 0042 · Floor order · 5 shared headingsSenate invokes cloture on permitting substitute SA 6883 to H.R. 2347, 70-27, starting up to 30 hours of post-cloture debate
- No. 0037 · Floor order · 5 shared headingsSenate takes up H.R. 2347 after 73-25 cloture vote; Capito substitute SA 6883 carries revised permitting text
- No. 0031 · Floor order · 5 shared headingsSenate order sets Nov. 9 cloture vote on motion to proceed to H.R. 2347, the vehicle for a permitting package