Register entry No. 0044Report117 FERC ¶ 61,331 (as cited in the complaint)
FERC gives PJM until Dec. 21 to answer Exelon's prompt-auction complaint, Docket No. EL27-11
Exelon asks the Commission to end the three-year forward period in PJM's Reliability Pricing Model and hold each capacity auction two months before delivery, starting with 2030/2031. It wanted an order by Jan. 31; a notice at 91 FR 74547 sets answers, comments and interventions for Dec. 21.
- Entered by
- Public Record Service
- Date
- Sources
- 6 cited
Summary
Exelon Corporation asked the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to rule by January 31, 2027. The Commission’s first procedural step lengthens the schedule instead: a notice issued November 13 and published November 19 at 91 FR 74547 grants PJM Interconnection’s motion for more time and sets December 21, 2026 as the deadline for PJM’s answer, comments and interventions in Docket No. EL27-11-000 [1]. Exelon’s complaint, filed November 3 under Federal Power Act sections 206, 306 and 309, asks the Commission to find the three-year forward period of PJM’s Reliability Pricing Model (RPM) unjust and unreasonable and to replace it with a “prompt” auction held two months before each delivery year, starting with 2030/2031 [2].
What the record shows
The relief requested
The complaint’s conclusion lists four requests [2]:
| Request | Terms |
|---|---|
| Section 206 finding | The current three-year forward period of RPM “is no longer just and reasonable” |
| Replacement rate | A prompt auction “to run two months before a given Delivery Year,” from 2030/2031 on |
| Refund effective date | January 1, 2027 |
| Fast Track processing | An order “by no later than January 31, 2027,” the last day before PJM is scheduled to post planning parameters for the 2030/2031 Base Residual Auction (BRA) |
The two-month interval is a recommendation, not a fixed demand. Exelon acknowledges the Commission’s “wide legal discretion” in setting a replacement rate and says two months fits between PJM’s late-January load forecast and the June 1 start of a delivery year [2].
The complaint carves out the near term. It says nothing in it is intended to “apply to, or otherwise disrupt the implementation of, the 2029/2030 Delivery Year BRA,” scheduled for December 2026, or any Reliability Backstop Procurement auction, citing the Third Circuit’s 2024 decision in PJM Power Providers Group v. FERC because the 2029/2030 planning parameters have already been posted [2]. The practical effect Exelon describes is to move the 2030/2031 BRA from May 2027 “to approximately March 2030” [2].
Exelon’s case against the forward period
Exelon builds its argument on the Commission’s own 2006 reasoning. In the April 2006 order accepting RPM, the Commission agreed that a forward estimate “may turn out to be inaccurate” but found that risk reasonable “when it is compared to the risks of the current construct, namely that sufficient capacity resources may not be constructed to ensure the preservation of reliability” [2]. The complaint contends that this balance “has fundamentally collapsed in 2026” because forecast error has grown while new plants can no longer be built inside the three-year window [2].
The supporting figures come from the affidavit of Dr. Emma Nicholson [2]:
- Load adjustments in PJM’s forecast model, no more than 2% of projected summer peak four to five years out in the 2017 through 2021 forecasts, reached 18.4% and 21.7% in the 2026 forecast [2].
- The summer peak forecasts for 2027 through 2029 fell between 2.3% and 2.6% from the January 2025 forecast to the January 2026 forecast [2].
- On an illustrative demand curve built from 2029/2030 parameters without a price collar, a 1% or 2% lower reliability requirement translates to “approximately $6 to $12 billion” in total capacity costs [2].
- The 2027/2028 and 2028/2029 BRAs cleared at the price cap and fell short of the reliability requirement by 6,517 MW and 6,831 MW of unforced capacity [2].
- About 24 GW of planned generation with executed interconnection agreements, including 13.5 GW of gas, has terminated since 2020, and a Johns Hopkins study cited in the affidavit found an average of 10.8 years from queue entry to operation for large gas plants [2].
The complaint also quotes PJM’s May 6, 2026 white paper, which said the three-year assumption behind RPM “has been physically broken” [2]. Exelon notes that the Commission has found prompt auction schedules just and reasonable for ISO New England, the New York ISO and MISO [2].
Where it sits in the process
Why does FERC’s Dec. 21 deadline matter for the Jan. 31 date?
Under Rule 206, answers, interventions and comments on a complaint are due within 20 days of filing unless the Commission orders otherwise [6]. PJM put that default date at November 23 and asked for four more weeks [3]. Fast Track processing under Rule 206(h) lets the Commission shorten the answer period and act on the pleadings on an expedited basis [6]; the November 13 notice instead lengthened the period [1].
The notice summarizes both sides. PJM said the extra time would let it fold in the outcome of the PJM Board’s November 17 deliberations and that Exelon had shown no “compelling reason” for action by January 31 [1]. Exelon, in a November 9 answer, supported an extension only to December 7, called PJM’s request “excessive for the narrow scope of the allegations,” and urged action well before the May 2027 auction [1]. The Commission granted PJM’s date: “the deadline to file the answer to Exelon’s complaint, comments, and interventions is December 21, 2026” [1]. The notice cites 16 U.S.C. 824e as authority [1].
That leaves about six weeks between the close of the pleadings and the date Exelon named, by this report’s count.
What the statute sets
Section 206(b) requires a refund effective date in any complaint proceeding, no earlier than the filing date and no later than five months after it [5]. For a November 3 filing, that outer bound falls in early April 2027, by this report’s count. The statute also requires the Commission to explain itself if no final decision issues within 180 days of the proceeding’s start [5]. Refunds can reach back to the refund effective date for up to 15 months [5].
What the record does not show
- The Board’s decision. PJM’s motion said the Board would consider “the path forward for the Base Residual Auction for the 2030/2031 Delivery Year” on November 17 and that its determinations would “substantially inform” PJM’s answer [3]. No Board decision on that auction appears in the record this report draws on.
- A ruling on fast track. The notice grants the extension but does not address Exelon’s fast-track request in its own words [1].
- Whether planning parameters will post on schedule. Exelon treats the January 31 date as the last clean point for a change [2]. PJM argues legal consequences attach only when sellers submit binding offers, not when parameters are posted, and that its tariff already allows parameter updates in some circumstances [3]. The Commission has not said which view it holds.
- Interaction with other dockets. Exelon says, to its knowledge, the question is not pending in any other proceeding in which it is a party [2]. The complaint does cite the Reliability Backstop Procurement dockets, ER26-3380-000 and EL26-108-000, which the Commission accepted and suspended on September 30 [2]. How a prompt BRA would sit alongside 15-year backstop contracts is argued by Exelon but not addressed by PJM’s preliminary filing [2, 3].
- Conforming changes. Exelon concedes other PJM governing agreements may need revision if it wins, without listing them [2].
- Other parties. No interventions or comments from states, consumer advocates or generators were public as of publication; the window runs to December 21 [1].
Positions on the record
Exelon. The utility holding company says it serves more than 10.7 million customers in PJM through six utilities, among them ComEd, PECO and BGE [2]. Its complaint calls RPM in its current structure “fundamentally broken” and says customers “are paying for a widening gap between supply and demand” [2]. Exelon frames the prompt auction as interim: the “targeted surgery requested in this complaint will not heal all that ails RPM,” but would buy time for a broader redesign [2].
PJM. The grid operator’s November 4 filing contests only the fast-track request for now [3]. It argues that fast track is meant for “comparatively straightforward tariff disputes” and that the complaint “challenges a foundational element” of RPM [3]. PJM also states that it “disagrees with Exelon’s assertion that a prompt auction is just and reasonable on its own” without complementary changes, and says it is developing revisions to multiple governing documents for filing by the end of the year, alongside its white paper process [3]. Utility Dive reported that a PJM spokesman said the grid operator was reviewing the complaint and would respond in due course, and that PJM had received more than 30 stakeholder responses to the white paper ahead of a November 13 workshop [4].
Refunds. PJM’s filing argues that section 206 refund authority means the Commission need not rule before parameters post, but adds: “the Commission has historically been reluctant to order refunds with respect to final market results, and PJM has opposed such requests for refund relief” [3].
Reading-room questions
Questions readers bring to this record, answered from the documents cited below.
- When are comments due on Exelon's complaint against PJM?
- December 21, 2026. The Commission's notice in Docket No. EL27-11-000 set that date for PJM's answer and for all comments and interventions [1].
- What is Exelon asking FERC to change in PJM's capacity market?
- It asks FERC to find the three-year forward period of PJM's Reliability Pricing Model unjust and unreasonable under FPA section 206 and replace it with an auction run two months before each delivery year, beginning with 2030/2031 [2].
- Would Exelon's complaint affect the December 2026 PJM capacity auction?
- No. The complaint says nothing in it is intended to apply to the 2029/2030 Base Residual Auction scheduled for December 2026, or to any Reliability Backstop Procurement auction [2].
Note on sourcing
The complaint's figures on load forecast adjustments, auction shortfalls, turbine backlogs and the $6 billion to $12 billion cost range are Exelon's and its witness Dr. Emma Nicholson's, and have not been tested by PJM or the Commission; PJM's merits answer is not due until December 21. Exelon's November 9 answer to PJM's motion is described here as the Commission's notice summarizes it; its text is not quoted. The notice grants PJM's extension but does not state in terms whether the Commission has ruled on Exelon's request for Fast Track processing. Any action the PJM Board took on the 2030/2031 Base Residual Auction at its November 17 meeting had not been made public as of publication. The outer limit for a refund effective date is this report's own count from the statute and the filing date.
Sources
- Exelon Corporation v. PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.; Notice Establishing Comment Period, 91 FR 74547 (FR Doc. 2026-23611), Docket No. EL27-11-000Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, November 19, 2026 ·
govinfo.gov - Complaint Requesting Fast Track Processing of Exelon Corporation, Docket No. EL27-11-000Exelon Corporation, November 3, 2026 ·
pjm.com - Preliminary Answer of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. Opposing Fast-Track Processing and Motion for Extension of Time to Answer, Docket No. EL27-11-000PJM Interconnection, November 4, 2026 ·
pjm.com - Exelon, Invenergy complaints at FERC seek capacity market changesUtility Dive, November 5, 2026 ·
utilitydive.com - 16 U.S. Code § 824e, Power of Commission to fix rates and chargesU.S. Congress, accessed 2026-11-19 ·
law.cornell.edu - 18 CFR § 385.206, Complaints (Rule 206)Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, accessed 2026-11-19 ·
law.cornell.edu
Subject headings
Cross-references
Other register entries filed under the same subject headings.
- No. 0011 · Report · 2 shared headingsFERC opens post-conference comment on PJM governance reforms, Docket No. AD26-7, with filings due Aug. 21
- No. 0042 · Floor order · 1 shared headingSenate invokes cloture on permitting substitute SA 6883 to H.R. 2347, 70-27, starting up to 30 hours of post-cloture debate
- No. 0040 · Report · 1 shared headingDelfin LNG asks FERC for a sixth extension, to 2030, for its onshore facilities, Docket No. CP15-490-005